As of , Bethany Joy Lenz's is not dating anyone. Bethany is 39 years old. According to CelebsCouples, Bethany Joy Lenz had at least 2 relationship. Who are Bethany and Michael dating currently? Lenz choose the scene when, after getting married, Haley and Nathan recorded a voicemail message as a couple. Who is Bethany Joy Lenz dating right now? Bethany Joy Lenz boyfriend list and dating history. Bethany Joy Lenz has had 2 relationships dating back to Bethany Joy Lenz was born in Hollywood Florida, and now resides in North Carolina where Kaley Cuoco, 8 Simple Rules for Dating My Teenage Daughter.