For one of the most unforgettable anniversary date ideas, find a private No matter what season your anniversary falls in, a getaway to a crisp. 1 year – PAPER: a classic gift for your first anniversary is a passionately written, old-fashioned love letter. · 2 years – COTTON: a fun idea is to get a matching pair. If you're nostalgic, like me, the anniversary of your first date always has a special place in your heart. And then, of course, there's the one-year. One year dating gift first year together gifts for 1st year 2nd year dating Anniversary Gift for Him, Travel Gift, Adventure Awaits, Dating ideas, Birthday Gifts For.