Curious about first-time anal sex? We consulted with a sex therapist on how to do anal to make the experience as smooth and sexy as possible. The ins and outs of anal sex, including the best tips, positions, and Now, hold your horses: The key to first-time anal sex is going slow, Vrangalova says. "Shit happens, literally, when you play with anal," Vrangalova says. How do you have anal sex for the first time? I've been considering trying some butt stuff out but I don't really know how? Your First Time Anal Sex Questions Answered By Women Who've Had It Woman E: Over time, you know what to expect and how to enjoy it.